Venice Commission :: Council of Europe

CDL-PI(2024)023 Engl./Fr. 13/06/2024 - Public
Ukraine - Information on the follow-up to the Opinion on the Law on the prevention of threats to national security, associated with excessive influence of persons having significant economic or political weight in public life (oligarchs) (CDL-AD(2023)018), presented at the 138th Plenary Session (Venice, 15-16 March 2024) / Ukraine - Information sur les suites données à l’Avis sur la Loi sur la prévention des menaces pour la sécurité nationale liées à l'influence excessive de personnes ayant un poids économique ou politique important dans la vie publique (oligarques) (CDL-AD(2023)018), présentée lors de la 138e session plénière (Venise, 15-16 mars 2024)

CDL-REF(2024)001 English 22/01/2024 - Public
Ukraine - Law 10288 "On Amendments to certain Law of Ukraine concerning the consideration of the expert assessment of the COuncil of Europe and its bodies on the rights of National Minorities (Communities)" in specific spheres

CDL-PI(2023)028 Engl./Fr. 20/12/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Information on the follow-up to the Urgent follow-up opinion to the opinions on the Law "On Amendments to certain legislative acts of Ukraine to clarify the provisions on the competitive selection of candidates for the position of judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine" (CDL-AD(2023)042), / Ukraine - Informations sur les suites données à l’Avis urgent sur les suites données aux avis sur la loi « Portant modification de certains actes législatifs d'Ukraine visant à clarifier les dispositions sur la sélection compétitive des candidats au poste de juge de la Cour constitutionnelle d'Ukraine » (CDL-AD(2023)042), entériné par lors de la 136e session plénière (Venise, 6-7 octobre 2023)

CDL-REF(2023)047 English 26/09/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Law on Amendments to the Law "On National Minorities (Communities)" on Certain Issues of Exercising Rights and Freedoms of Persons Belonging to National Minorities (Communities)

CDL-REF(2023)037 English 20/09/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Law "On amendments to certain legislative acts of Ukraine to clarify provisions on the competitive selection of candidates for the position of judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine"

CDL-REF(2023)044 English 15/09/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Law on Amendments to Certain Laws of Ukraine (on restriction of participation of persons associated with political parties whose activities are prohibited in the government)

CDL-REF(2023)043 English 15/09/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Law on Amendments to the Law "On National Minorities (Communities)" on Certain Issues of Exercising Rights and Freedoms of Persons Belonging to National Minorities (Communities) and Explanatory Note

CDL-REF(2023)041 English 12/09/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Law on Amending the Law of Ukraine “On the Judiciary and the Status of Judges” as regards Introduction of Additional Procedures to Enhance Public Trust in the Judiciary and Explanatory Note

CDL-REF(2023)039 English 11/09/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Law on Amendments to Article 51 of the Rules of Procedure of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on political liability of Members of Parliament of Ukraine associated with political parties whose activities have been suspended

CDL-PI(2023)016 Engl./Fr. 13/06/2023 - Public
Ukraine – Information on the follow-up to the Urgent joint opinion on the draft law on amendments to certain legislative acts concerning the procedure for electing (appointing) members of the HCJ and the activities of disciplinary inspectors of the HCJ (Draft law no. 5068) (CDL-AD(2021)018) and Joint Amicus curiae brief on certain questions related to the election and discipline of the members of the HCJ (CDL-AD(2022)023) / Information sur les suites données à l'avis conjoint urgent sur le projet de loi portant modification de certains actes législatifs concernant la procédure d'élection (de nomination) des membres du HCJ et les activités des inspecteurs disciplinaires du HCJ (projet de loi n° 5068) (CDL-AD(2021)018) et Mémoire amicus curiae conjoint sur certaines questions liées à l'élection et la discipline des membres du HCJ (CDL-AD(2022)023)

CDL-REF(2023)025 English 25/05/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Comparative Table: Draft Law «On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts as Regards Clarification of the Individual Clauses on the Procedure for the Competitive Selection of the Candidates for the Position of a Judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine»

CDL-REF(2023)019 English 28/04/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Law of the Land "On national minorities (communities) of Ukraine"

CDL-REF(2023)018 English 27/04/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Law “On amending some legislative acts of Ukraine regarding improving procedure for selecting candidate Judges of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on a competitive basis”

CDL-PI(2023)002 English 25/01/2023 - Public
Ukraine - Follow-up to the Opinion CDL-AD (2022)054

CDL-PI(2023)002 Ukrainian 25/01/2023 - Public
Україна – Про заходи вжиті на основі Висновку CDL-AD (2022)054

CDL-PI(2022)046 French 23/11/2022 - Public
Ukraine – Avis urgent sur le projet de loi « Portant modification de certains actes législatifs de l'Ukraine visant à améliorer la procédure de sélection compétitive des candidats au poste de juge de la Cour constitutionnelle de l'Ukraine », rendu le 23 novembre 2022 en vertu de l'article 14a du règlement intérieur de la Commission de Venise.

CDL-PI(2022)046 English 23/11/2022 - Public
Ukraine – Urgent Opinion on the draft law “On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine on improving the procedure for the selection of candidates for the position of judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on a Competitive Basis”, issued on 23 November 2022, pursuant to Article 14a of the Venice Commission's Rules of Procedure.

CDL-REF(2022)059 English 15/11/2022 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law on amending some legislative acts of Ukraine regarding improving procedure for selecting candidate justices of the Constitutional court of Ukraine on a competitive basis

CDL(2022)041 English 30/09/2022 - Public
Ukraine - Draft joint amicus curiae brief of the Venice Commission and the Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law (DGI) of the Council of Europe on certain questions related to the election and discipline of the members of the High Council of Justice (H. SUCHOCKA, N. EȘANU, G. REISSNER, M. KUIJER)

CDL(2022)008 English 03/06/2022 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Amicus Curiae brief on the limits of subsequent (a posteriori) review of constitutional amendments by the Constitutional Court (J. VELAERS, A. NUSSBERGER, J. VARGAS VALDEZ)

CDL-REF(2022)004 English 03/02/2022 - Public
Ukraine- Law of Ukraine “On the Constitutional Court of Ukraine”

CDL-REF(2022)002 English 19/01/2022 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law on local referendum

CDL(2021)049 English 23/11/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Joint Opinion of the Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR on the draft law “On Improving The Procedure For Establishing The Impossibility Of Holding National And Local Elections, All-Ukrainian And Local Referenda In Certain Territories And Polling Stations” (R. BARRETT, P. BIGLINO CAMPOS, M. MORRY)

CDL-REF(2021)086 English 15/11/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Law on the prevention of threats to national security, associated with excessive influence of persons having significant economic or political weight in social life (oligarchs)

CDL-REF(2021)082 English 20/10/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Law on High Council of Justice

CDL-REF(2021)081 English 20/10/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Law on amending selected legislative acts concerning procedure for election (appointment) of members of the High Council of Justice and activities of disciplinary inspectors of the High Council of Justices

CDL-REF(2021)080 English 20/10/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Law on the judiciary and the status of judges

CDL-REF(2021)079 English 20/10/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Law on amendments to the Law "on the judiciary and the status of judges" and selected laws regarding the resumption of operation of the high qualifications commission of judges

CDL-REF(2021)077 English 07/10/2021 - Public
Ukraine-Draft law “On Improving The Procedure For Establishing The Impossibility Of Holding National And Local Elections, All-Ukrainian And Local Referenda In Certain Territories And Polling Stations”

CDL-REF(2021)055 English 17/08/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Law of Ukraine On the Principles of the Public Transitional Policy

CDL(2021)030 English 23/07/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Opinion on the draft law “On the principles of state policy of the transition period” (A. NUSSBERGER, V. BÍLKOVÁ, M. KUIJER)

CDL-PI(2021)010 English 05/05/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Joint Urgent opinion of the Venice Commission and the Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law of the Council of Europe, on the draft Law amending provisions of the Code of Administrative offences and the Criminal Code regarding the liability of public officials for inaccurate asset declaration (No. 4651 OF 27 January 2021), issued pursuant to Article 14a of the Venice Commission’s Rules of Procedure.

CDL-PI(2021)010 Ukrainian 05/05/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Joint Urgent opinion of the Venice Commission and the Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law of the Council of Europe, on the draft Law amending provisions of the Code of Administrative offences and the Criminal Code regarding the liability of public officials for inaccurate asset declaration (No. 4651 OF 27 January 2021)

CDL-PI(2021)010 French 05/05/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Avis conjoint urgent de la Commission de Venise et de la Direction générale des droits de l'homme et de l'Etat de droit du Conseil de l'Europe sur le projet de loi modifiant les dispositions du Code des infractions administratives et du Code pénal concernant la responsabilité des fonctionnaires en cas de déclaration de patrimoine inexacte et du Code pénal concernant la responsabilité des agents publics en cas de déclaration de patrimoine inexacte (n° 4651 du 27 janvier 2021), rendu en vertu de l'article 14a du règlement intérieur de la Commission de Venise.

CDL-PI(2021)004 English 05/05/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Urgent joint opinion of the Venice Commission and the Directorate General of Human Rights and the Rule of Law (DGI) of the Council of Europe on the draft law on amendments to certain legislative acts concerning the procedure for electing (appointing) members of the High Council of Justice (HCJ) and the activities of disciplinary inspectors of the HCJ (Draft law no. 5068), issued pursuant to Article 14a of the Venice Commission’s Rules of Procedure

CDL-PI(2021)004 Ukrainian 05/05/2021 - Public
Україна - Терміновий спільний висновок Венеційської Комісії та Генерального Директорату з Прав людини та Верховенства права (ГД 1) Ради Європи щодо законопроєкту "Про внесення змін до деяких законів України щодо порядку обрання (призначення) на посади членів Вищої Ради Правосуддя (ВРП) та діяльності дисциплінарних інспекторів ВРП" (Законопроєкт № 5068) - Ukraine - Urgent joint opinion of the Venice Commission and the Directorate General of Human Rights and the Rule of Law (DGI) of the Council of Europe on the draft law on amendments to certain legislative acts concerning the procedure for electing (appointing) members of the High Council of Justice (HCJ) and the activities of disciplinary inspectors of the HCJ (Draft law no. 5068)

CDL-PI(2021)004 French 05/05/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Avis conjoint urgent de la Commission de Venise et la Direction Générale Droits de l’Homme et Etat de Droit (DGI) sur le projet de loi portant modification de certains actes législatifs concernant la procédure d'élection (de nomination) des membres du Haut Conseil de la Justice (HCJ) et les activités des inspecteurs disciplinaires du HCJ (projet de loi n° 5068), rendu en vertu de l'article 14a du règlement intérieur de la Commission de Venise

CDL-REF(2021)034 English 27/04/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Consolidated text of the Code on Administrative Offenses and the Criminal Code with the amendments proposed by draft law no. 4561 (of 27 January 2021) proposed by the President of Ukraine (increasing the liability of public officials for declaring inaccurate information in the asset declarations and the failure to submit such declarations)

CDL-REF(2021)030 English 29/03/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Law on the procedure for electing (appointing) members of the High Council of Justice and on the activities of disciplinary inspectors of the High Council of Justice (Reg. no 5068)

CDL(2021)013 English 05/03/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Opinion on the draft law on Constitutional Procedure (draft law no. 4533) and alternative draft law on the procedure for consideration of cases and execution of judgements of the Constitutional Court (draft law no. 4533 -1) (C. GRABENWARTER, S. DARMANOVIĆ, P. CAROZZA)

CDL-REF(2021)016 English 09/02/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law no. 4533-1 on the procedure for hearing of cases and implementation of decisions of the Constitutional Court

CDL-REF(2021)015 English 09/02/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law no. 4533 on the Constitutional Procedure

CDL(2021)005 English 05/02/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Joint Opinion on the Draft Law on Political Parties (J. VELAERS, P. VILANOVA TRIAS, M. FRENDO)

CDL-REF(2021)006 English 22/01/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Law of Ukraine on Political Parties in Ukraine

CDL-REF(2021)005 English 22/01/2021 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law on political parties

CDL-PI(2020)019 English 10/12/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Urgent opinion on the Reform of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine issued pursuant to Article 14a of the Venice Commission’s Rules of Procedure (C. GRABENWARTER, S. DARMANOVIĆ, M. CARTABIA, P. CAROZZA)

CDL-REF(2020)078add English 07/12/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Decision No. 13-r/2020 of the Constitution Court of Ukraine of 27 October 2020, with dissenting opinions

CDL-REF(2020)079 English 01/12/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Law on Prevention of Corruption of 2014, as amended

CDL-REF(2020)078 English 01/12/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Decision No. 13-r/2020 of the Constitution Court of Ukraine of 27 October 2020, with dissenting opinions

CDL(2020)037 English 25/09/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Draft opinion on the draft amendments to the Law 'on the Judiciary and the Status of Judges' and certain Laws on the activities of the Supreme Court and Judicial Authorities (H. SUCHOCKA, N. EȘANU, G. REISSNER, M. KUIJER)

CDL-REF(2020)068 English 09/09/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Law on the Organisation of Courts and the Status of Judges

CDL-REF(2020)067 English 09/09/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Law on the High Council of Justice

CDL-REF(2020)063 English 04/09/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Law on the High Anti-Corruption Court

CDL-REF(2020)061 English 28/08/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Draft amendments to the Law "On the Judiciary and the Status of Judges" and certain laws on the activities of the Supreme Court and judicial authorities

CDL-PI(2020)009 English 21/07/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Urgent Joint Opinion on draft Law 3612 on democracy through all-Ukraine referendum, issued pursuant to Article 14a of the Venice Commission’s Rules of Procedure (M. MORRY, N. ALIVIZATOS, J. CASTELLÀ ANDREU)

CDL-PI(2020)009 French 21/07/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Avis conjoint urgent sur le projet de loi 3612 sur la démocratie par un référendum pan-ukrainien, rendu en vertu de l'article 14a du règlement intérieur de la Commission de Venise (M. MORRY, N. ALIVIZATOS, J. CASTELLÀ ANDREU)

CDL-REF(2020)029 English 10/06/2020 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law “on Democracy through All-Ukrainian Referendum”

CDL(2019)042 English 22/11/2019 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Opinion on the Legal framework in Ukraine governing the Supreme Court and judicial self-governing bodies (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, N. EȘANU, E. HOLMØYVIK)

CDL(2019)038 English 22/11/2019 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Opinion on the Law supporting the Functioning of the Ukrainian Language as the State Language (R. HOFMANN, H. KJERULF THORGEIRSDOTTIR, J. VELAERS, V. BÍLKOVÁ)

CDL(2019)045 English 20/11/2019 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Amicus Curiae Brief for the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on the early termination of the mandate of Members of Parliament (N. ALIVIZATOS, J. CASTELLÀ ANDREU, E. HOLMØYVIK, T. OTTY)

CDL-REF(2019)039 English 20/11/2019 - Public
Ukraine - Law No. 193 of Ukraine "on amending certain laws of Ukraine regarding activity of judicial governance bodies" and explanatory note

CDL-REF(2019)036 English 18/11/2019 - Public
Ukraine - Law on Supporting the Functioning of the Ukrainian Language as the State Language

CDL(2019)013 English 01/03/2019 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Amicus Curiae Brief on separate appeals against rulings on preventive measures (deprivation of liberty) of first instance courts (A. VARGA, M. KUIJER, A. BARAMIDZE)

CDL-JU(2018)017 English 29/10/2018 - Public
Report "Opinion of the Venice Commission on the draft Law on the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, by Ms Hanna Suchocka, International Conference "Individual Constitutional Complaint to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, Kiev, Ukraine, 10 September 2018 (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL-JU(2018)016 English 29/10/2018 - Public
Report "The individual constitutional complaint (Verfassungsbeschwerde) in German Law with comparative references to Ukrainian Law, by Mr Rainer Arnold, International Conference "Individual constitutional complaint to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine", Kiev, Ukraine, 10 September 2018 (R. ARNOLD)

CDL-JU(2018)015 English 29/10/2018 - Public
Report "Normative constitutional complaint in Ukraine as a national legal remedy" by Mr Mykhailo Hultai, International Conference "Individual constitutional complaint to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine", Kiev, Ukraine, 10 September 2018 (M. HULTAI)

CDL-JU(2018)014 English 29/10/2018 - Public
Report on "Constitutional Complaint in Poland and Ukraine" by Mr Miroslaw Granat, International Conference "Individual Constitutional Complaint to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine", Kiev, Ukraine, 10 September 2018 (M. GRANAT)

CDL-JU(2018)013 English 29/10/2018 - Public
Report of the nature and importance of judicial reasoning in the jurisprudence of the Constitutional courts by Mr Alexandru Tanase, International Conference "Individual constitutional complaint to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine", Kiev, Ukraine, 10 September 2018 (A. TĂNASE)

CDL(2018)001 English 23/02/2018 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Joint Opinion on Draft Law No. 6674 "On Introducing Changes to Some Legislative Acts to Ensure Public Transparency of Information on Finance Activity of Public Associations and of the Use of International Technical Assistance" and on Draft Law No. 6675 "On Introducing Changes to the Tax Code of Ukraine to Ensure Public Transparency of the Financing of Public Associations and of the Use of International Technical Assistance" (J. SØRENSEN, R. CLAYTON QC, V. POGHOSYAN)

CDL(2018)001 French 23/02/2018 - Public
Ukraine - Projet d'avis conjoint relatif au projet de loi no 6674 portant modification de certains actes législatifs pour garantir la transparence de l’information sur l’activité financière des associations publiques et de l’utilisation de l’assistance technique internationale et au projet de loi no 6675 portant modification du code général des impôts de l’ukraine pour garantir la transparence du financement es associations publiques et de l’utilisation de l’assistance technique internationale (J. SØRENSEN, R. CLAYTON QC, V. POGHOSYAN)

CDL-REF(2018)005 English 24/01/2018 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law no. 6674 on introducing changes to some legislative acts to ensure public transparency of information on finance activity of public associations and on the use of international technical assistance

CDL-REF(2018)004 English 24/01/2018 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law no. 6675 on introducing changes to the tax code of Ukraine to ensure public transparency of the financing of public associations and the use of international technical assistance

CDL(2017)040 English 24/11/2017 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Opinion on the provisions of the Law on Education of 5 September 2017, which concern the use of the State Language and Minority and other Languages in Education (S. BARTOLE, J. VELAERS, M. FRENDO)

CDL-REF(2017)051 English 17/11/2017 - Public
Ukraine - Ministry of Education and Science position on Article 7 of the Law on Education

CDL-REF(2017)047 English 17/11/2017 - Public
Ukraine - The Law on Education adopted by the Verkhovna Rada on 5 September 2017 (for issue of language, see Article 7 and Concluding Remarks and Transitional Provision N° 18)

CDL(2017)027 English 22/09/2017 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Opinion on the amendments to the Rules of procedure of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2017)038 English 08/09/2017 - Public
Ukraine - Law on amendments to the Rules of Parliamentary Procedure

CDL-REF(2017)037 English 07/09/2017 - Public
Ukraine - Law on the Rules of Procedure of the Verkhovna Rada

CDL-REF(2017)036 English 28/08/2017 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law on the amendments to the Law of Ukraine on the Judiciary and the Status of Judges concerning the introduction of compulsory specialization of judges for the consideration of corruptive delinquencies and those related to corruption

CDL-REF(2017)035 English 28/08/2017 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Law of Ukraine on Anticorruption Courts

CDL(2017)020 English 22/08/2017 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on Anticorruption Courts and on the Draft Law on Amendments to the Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges (concerning the introduction of mandatory specialisation of judges on the consideration of corruption and corruption-related offences) (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, G. PAPUASHVILI, J. SØRENSEN, A. ANASTAS)

CDL-REF(2016)066add English 05/12/2016 - Public
Ukraine - Draft law on the Constitutional Court

CDL(2016)042 English 25/11/2016 - Public
Ukraine - Draft opinion on the draft law on the Constitutional Court (C. GRABENWARTER, H. SUCHOCKA, W. HOFFMANN-RIEM, O. CAN)

CDL(2016)042 French 25/11/2016 - Public
Ukraine - Projet d'avis relatif au projet de loi sur la Cour constitutionnelle (C. GRABENWARTER, H. SUCHOCKA, W. HOFFMANN-RIEM, O. CAN)

CDL-REF(2016)066 English 24/11/2016 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Law on the Constitutional Court

CDL-JU(2016)015 English 21/11/2016 - Public
International Conference "The role and significance of the "Rule of Law checklist", adopted at the 106th Plenary Session of the Venice Commission, in the process of conducting constitutional monitoring and the role of Constitutional Courts in overcoming the legal gaps, and legal uncertainty, Yerevan, Armenia, 20-22 October 2016, Report by Serhiy Holovaty on the Concept of the Rule of Law - Difficulties of its perception in the post-Soviet legal culture (Ukraine’s experience) (S. HOLOVATY)

CDL(2016)036 English 07/10/2016 - Public
Draft joint opinion by the Venice Commission, the Directorate of Human Rights (DGI) and the OSCE/ODIHR on Draft Law N° 3587 on guarantees for freedom of peaceful assembly and Draft Law N° 3587-1 on guarantees for freedom of peaceful assembly (L. HUSEYNOV, A. VASHKEVICH, N. EȘANU, C. BAZY MALAURIE)

CDL-REF(2016)046 English 05/07/2016 - Public
Ukraine - Draft Law n°3587 on guarantees for freedom of peaceful assembly and Draft Law n°3587-1 on guarantees for freedom of peaceful assembly in Ukraine

CDL(2016)024 English 27/05/2016 - Public
Draft opinion on the amendments to the law of Ukraine on elections regarding the exclusion of candidates from party lists. (P. PACZOLAY, P. VILANOVA TRIAS, M. FRENDO)

CDL-REF(2016)040 English 23/05/2016 - Public
Law on elections of the people’s deputies of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2016)024 English 06/04/2016 - Public
The Law on amending the law of Ukraine “On elections of people’s deputies of Ukraine” as to the exclusion of candidates for people’s deputies of Ukraine from party’s electoral list in a multi-mandate constituency

CDL(2015)057 English 07/12/2015 - Public
Secretariat Memorandum on the compatibility of the Draft Law of Ukraine on amending the Constitution of Ukraine as to Justice as submitted by the President to the Verkhovna Rada on 25 November 2015 with the Venice Commission's opinion on the proposed amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine regarding the Judiciary

CDL(2015)057 French 07/12/2015 - Public
Note du Secrétariat sur la compatibilité entre le projet de loi de revision de la Constitution de l'Ukraine concernant la justice tel que soumis par le Président à la Verkhovna Rada le 25 novembre 2015 (CDL-REF(2015)047) et l'avis de la Commission de Venise sur les projets d'amendements de la Constitution de l'Ukraine concernant le pouvoir judiciaire tel qu’approuvés par la Commission constitutionnelle le 4 septembre 2015 (CDL-AD(2015)027)

CDL(2015)050 English 04/12/2015 - Public
Draft joint opinion on the law of Ukraine on the condemnation of the communist and national socialist (Nazi) regimes and prohibition of propaganda of their symbols (H. SUCHOCKA, S. BARTOLE, I. BOEV, V. BÍLKOVÁ, R. KIENER)

CDL-REF(2015)047 English 03/12/2015 - Public
Draft Law on amending the Constitution of Ukraine as to justice introduced by the President of Ukraine to the Verkhovna Rada on 25 November 2015

CDL-REF(2015)045 English 28/10/2015 - Public
Law on the condemnation of the Communist and National Socialist (Nazi) regimes, and prohibition of propaganda of their symbols of Ukraine

CDL(2015)046 English 16/10/2015 - Public
Draft Interim Opinion on the Draft Law on Integrity Checking of Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, G. PAPUASHVILI, V. BÍLKOVÁ)

CDL(2015)040rev French 13/10/2015 - Public
Note du Secrétariat : Compatibilité entre le Projet de Loi de révision de la constitution de l'Ukraine concernant la décentralisation du pouvoir soumis par le Parlement à la Cour constitutionnelle ukrainienne

CDL(2015)040rev English 13/10/2015 - Public
Secretariat Memorandum: Compatibility of the Draft Law on amending the Constitution of Ukraine as to Decentralization of Power with Preliminary Opinion on the proposed constitutional amendments regarding the territorial structure and local administration of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2015)035rev English 13/10/2015 - Public
Draft Law on amending the constitution of Ukraine as to decentralization of power as submitted by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on 16 July 2015

CDL(2015)040 English 09/10/2015 - Public
Secretariat Memorandum: Compatibility of the Draft Law on amending the Constitution of Ukraine as to Decentralization of Power with Preliminary Opinion on the proposed constitutional amendments regarding the territorial structure and local administration of Ukraine

CDL(2015)039 English 09/10/2015 - Public
Draft Opinion on the proposed Constitutional Amendments regarding the Judiciary of Ukraine (J. SCHOLSEM, H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, G. PAPUASHVILI, E. TANCHEV, R. KIENER)

CDL-REF(2015)040 English 02/10/2015 - Public
Comparative Table : Revised proposals on amending the Constitution prepared by the Working Group on the Judiciary of the Constitutional Commission of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2015)031 English 30/09/2015 - Public
Draft Amendments to some legislative acts concerning the prevention of and fight against political corruption in Ukraine - Comparative table

CDL(2015)037 English 24/09/2015 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Temporal Validity of Draft Transitional Provision 18 of the Constitution of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, A. DELCAMP)

CDL-REF(2015)035 English 10/09/2015 - Public
Draft Law on amending the constitution of Ukraine as to decentralization of power as submitted by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on 16 July 2015

CDL(2015)035 English 03/09/2015 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on the draft amendments to some legislative acts concerning prevention and fight against political corruption of Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY, B. JOUAN, D. Smilov, R. KATZ, M. FRENDO, Q. REED)

CDL(2015)035 French 03/09/2015 - Public
Projet d'avis conjoint relatif à des projets de modification de quelques textes législatifs concernant la lutte contre la corruption politique et sa prévention en Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY, B. JOUAN, D. Smilov, R. KATZ, M. FRENDO, Q. REED)

CDL-REF(2015)033 English 02/09/2015 - Public
Draft Law on Integrity Checking of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2015)024 English 24/07/2015 - Public
Comparative table: Proposals on amending the Constitution prepared by the working group on Justice of the Constitutional Commission of Ukraine

CDL-PI(2015)016 English 24/07/2015 - Public
Preliminary Opinion on the proposed constitutional amendments regarding the judiciary of Ukraine (J. SCHOLSEM, H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, G. PAPUASHVILI, E. TANCHEV, R. KIENER)

CDL-PI(2015)016 French 24/07/2015 - Public
Avis préliminaire sur la proposition de révision constitutionnelle concernant le pouvoir judiciaire de l'Ukraine (J. SCHOLSEM, H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, G. PAPUASHVILI, E. TANCHEV, R. KIENER)

CDL-REF(2015)022 English 07/07/2015 - Public
Draft Law on amending the Constitution of Ukraine as to decentralization of power introduced by the President of Ukraine to the Verkhovna Rada on 1 July 2015

CDL-REF(2015)021 English 24/06/2015 - Public
Comparative Table relating to the Draft Law of Ukraine on amending the Constitution of Ukraine regarding Territorial Structure and Local Administration as proposed by the Working Group of the Constitutional Commission of Ukraine on 17 June 2015

CDL-PI(2015)008 English 24/06/2015 - Public
Preliminary Opinion on the Constitutional Amendments regarding the Territorial Structure and Local Administration of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, A. DELCAMP)

CDL-PI(2015)008 French 24/06/2015 - Public
Avis préliminaire sur le projet de révision de la Constitution concernant la structure territoriale et l'administration locale de l'Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, A. DELCAMP)

CDL(2015)023 English 09/06/2015 - Public
Draft Final Opinion on the Law on Government Cleansing (Lustration Law) of Ukraine as would result from the amendments submitted to the Verkhavna Rada on 21 April 2015 (H. SUCHOCKA, G. PAPUASHVILI, B. VERMEULEN, V. BÍLKOVÁ, A. PETERS, G. REISSNER)

CDL(2015)018 English 03/06/2015 - Public
Draft opinion on draft constitutional amendments on the immunity of the members of the parliament and judges of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, S. BARTOLE, K. TUORI)

CDL-REF(2015)015 English 04/05/2015 - Public
Comparative Table to the Draft Law of Ukraine amending the Law of Ukraine on Government Cleansing ("Lustration Law") and other relevant laws of Ukraine submitted to the Verkhovna Rada on 21 April 2015

CDL-AD(2015)008 French 09/04/2015 - Public
Avis préliminaire sur le projet de loi portant modification de la loi relative au système judiciaire et au statut des juges d'Ukraine, pris en note par la Commission de Venise à sa 102ème session plénière (Venise, 20-21 mars 2015)

CDL-AD(2015)008 English 09/04/2015 - Public
Preliminary Opinion on the Draft Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges of Ukraine, taken note by the Venice Commission at its 102th Plenary Session (Venice, 20-21 March 2015)

CDL(2015)011 English 09/03/2015 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion of the Venice Commission and the Directorate of Human Rights (DHR) of the Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law (DGI) of the Council of Europe on the Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges and Amendments to the Law on the High Council of Justice of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, J. SØRENSEN, G. REISSNER)

CDL-REF(2015)003 English 09/03/2015 - Public
Draft Law on amending the Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2015)006 English 06/03/2015 - Public
Draft law on introducing changes to the Constitution (on immunity of the members of the Ukrainian Parliament and Judges) of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2015)004 English 05/03/2015 - Public
Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges and Amendments to the Law on High Council of Justice of Ukraine

CDL(2015)004 English 09/02/2015 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on amending the Law on Judicial System and Status of Judges of Ukraine

CDL(2014)052 English 28/11/2014 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Law on Government cleansing (« Lustration Law ») of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, G. PAPUASHVILI, H. HAENEL, B. VERMEULEN, V. BÍLKOVÁ, A. PETERS, G. REISSNER)

CDL-REF(2014)047 English 05/11/2014 - Public
Law on the Public Prosecutor's Office of Ukraine (Unofficial translation)

CDL-REF(2014)046 English 21/10/2014 - Public
Law on Government Cleansing ("Lustration Law") of Ukraine

CDL-EL(2014)005prog English 06/10/2014 - Public
Workshop on electoral dispute resolution, Tuesday 7 October 2014 - Draft programme

CDL(2014)034 English 24/07/2014 - Public
Preliminary opinion on the Draft law amending the Constitution of Ukraine, submitted by the President of Ukraine on 2 July 2014 (J. SCHOLSEM, H. SUCHOCKA, S. BARTOLE, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, G. PAPUASHVILI, E. TANCHEV, A. DELCAMP, G. Marcou, R. KIENER)

CDL(2014)034 French 24/07/2014 - Public
Avis préliminaire sur le projet de loi portant modification de la constitution de l'Ukraine soumis par le Président de l'Ukraine le 2 juillet 2014 (J. SCHOLSEM, H. SUCHOCKA, S. BARTOLE, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, G. PAPUASHVILI, E. TANCHEV, A. DELCAMP, G. Marcou, R. KIENER)

CDL-REF(2014)027 English 08/07/2014 - Public
Comparative table with respect to the Draft Law on amending the Constitution of Ukraine

CDL(2014)019 English 14/03/2014 - Public
Draft Opinion on "whether the decision taken by the Supreme Council of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea in Ukraine to organise a referendum on becoming a constituent territory of the Russian Federation or restoring Crimea's 1992 constitution is compatible with constitutional principles" (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, E. TANCHEV)

CDL-REF(2014)012 English 13/03/2014 - Public
Constitution of Ukraine, text provided by the Ukrainian authorities on 13 March 2013

CDL(2013)054 English 29/11/2013 - Public
Draft Opinion on Proposals amending the Draft Law "On Amendments to the Constitution, Strengthening the Independence of Judges" of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, J. HAMILTON, E. TANCHEV)

CDL-REF(2013)058 English 25/11/2013 - Public
Draft Law "On the amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine on the Enhancement of the Guarantes of the Independence of Judges" of Ukraine (with references to proposals for amendment by 156 Deputies of the Verkovna Rada) CDL-REF(2013)050)

CDL-REF(2013)050 English 14/11/2013 - Public
Proposals to the Draft law of Ukraine "On Amendments to the Constitution, Strengthening the Independance of Judges"

CDL(2013)037 English 26/09/2013 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on draft amendments to legislation on the election of people's deputies of Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY, J. PILGRIM)

CDL(2013)037 French 26/09/2013 - Public
Projet d’avis conjoint sur les projets d’amendements à la loi sur l’élection des députés d’Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY, J. PILGRIM)

CDL(2013)039 English 20/09/2013 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on the Prosecutor's Office of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, J. MCBRIDE, N. EȘANU, E. SVANIDZE, M. LYNGBO, L. BACHMAIER WINTER)

CDL-REF(2013)043 English 09/09/2013 - Public
Comparative table to section 12 of Draft Law on the Public Prosecutor's Office of Ukraine

CDL-JU(2013)009 Russian 09/09/2013 - Public
"The Role of the Constitutional Court of Azerbaijan in the Implementation of the European Convention on Human Rights" in Russian (L. HUSEYNOV)

CDL-REF(2013)042 English 05/09/2013 - Public
Evaluation of the recommendations expressed in the joint opinion by the Venice Commission and OSCE/ODIHR on June 2013 on the draft law of ukraine "on amendments to certain legislative acts of Ukraine as regards the improvement of legislation on elections"

CDL-REF(2013)039 English 05/09/2013 - Public
Draft amendments to the Code of Ukraine on administrative offences; the Law of Ukraine on political parties; the Code on administrative proceedings, the Law on the information agencies; the Law on the Central Electoral Commission, the Law on the election of people’s deputies of Ukraine and the Law on the principles of state language policy

CDL-REF(2013)041 English 04/09/2013 - Public
The Law of Ukraine On the Public Prosecutor’s Office

CDL(2013)019 English 07/06/2013 - Public
Joint Opinion on the draft laws on election of peoples deputies and on Central Election Commission (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2013)019 French 07/06/2013 - Public
Projet d'avis conjoint sur les projets de loi sur l'élection des députés du peuple, sur la Commission Electorale Centrale et sur l'organisation de nouvelles élections de députés d'Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL-REF(2013)015 English 04/06/2013 - Public
Law of Ukraine on national referendum

CDL(2013)029 English 31/05/2013 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Law on National Referendum of Ukraine (K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO)

CDL(2013)025 English 31/05/2013 - Public
Draft opinion on the draft Law on the amendments to the Constitution, strengthening the independence of judges (including an explanatory note and a comparative table) and on the changes to the Constitution proposed by the Constitutional Assembly of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, J. HAMILTON, E. TANCHEV)

CDL-REF(2013)028 English 29/05/2013 - Public
Comparative table with additional proposals on amendments to the law of Ukraine "On election of people's deputies of Ukraine"

CDL-REF(2013)025 English 29/05/2013 - Public
Draft Amendments to the Electoral Legislation of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2013)020 English 03/05/2013 - Public
Changes to the Constitution of Ukraine proposed by the Constitutional Assembly and Draft Law on the amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine, strengthening the independence of judges (including an explanatory note and a comparative table)"

CDL(2012)068 English 28/09/2012 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on the Public Prosecutor's Office of Ukraine (prepared by the Ukrainian Commission on strengthening democracy and the rule of law) (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, J. SØRENSEN)

CDL-REF(2012)033 English 07/09/2012 - Public
Draft law on the public prosecutor's office of Ukraine

CDL-EL(2012)003 Russian 22/03/2012 - Public
Third Eastern Partnership Facility Programme meeting "Voters' lists and registers" - Hotel "Salute", Kyiv, 26-27 March 2012 - Programme

CDL(2011)101 English 02/12/2011 - Public
Draft opinion on the draft law on principles of the state language policy of Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, J. VELAERS)

CDL-REF(2011)061 English 23/11/2011 - Public
Law on principles of the state language in Ukraine

CDL-JU(2011)020syn English 10/10/2011 - Public
Conference celebrating the 15th anniversary of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on "the protection of human rights by bodies of constitutional justice : possibilities and problems of individual access - Kyiv, 16 September 2011 - Synopsis

CDL(2011)085 English 05/10/2011 - Public
Draft joint opinion on the draft law on freedom of assembly of Ukraine (J. HAMILTON, A. VASHKEVICH, S. BANIC, D. Goldberger, S. Ostaf, N. Jarman)

CDL(2011)059 English 03/10/2011 - Public
Draft joint opinion on the draft law on election of people's deputies of Ukraine (S. DARMANOVIĆ, A. ENDZIŅŠ, D. BISSON)

CDL(2011)087 English 29/09/2011 - Public
Draft joint opinion on the draft law amending the law on the judiciary and the status of judges and other legislative acts of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, S. Gass, P. Lemmens)

CDL(2011)070 English 29/09/2011 - Public
Draft joint opinion on the draft law on the bar and practice of law of Ukraine (D. MERIDOR, L. MIHAI, K. HELLER, R. MULLERAT, R. JOKUBAUSKAS)

CDL-JU(2011)018 Russian 23/09/2011 - Public
Conference "Protection of human rights by bodies of constitutional justice", Kiev, Ukraine, 16 September 2011 - Report - "Individual constitutional complaint : European trends of system development" (G. HARUTYUNYAN)

CDL(2011)077 English 16/09/2011 - Public
Comments on the draft law on amendments to the law on the judiciary and the status of judges and to other legal acts of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2011)076 English 16/09/2011 - Public
Comments on the draft law on amendments to the law on the judiciary and the status of judges and to other legal acts of Ukraine (J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2011)069 English 15/09/2011 - Public
Comments on the draft law on the bar and practice of law of Ukraine (K. HELLER)

CDL(2011)068 English 15/09/2011 - Public
Comments on the draft law on the bar and practice of law of Ukraine (L. MIHAI)

CDL(2011)067 English 15/09/2011 - Public
Comments on the draft law on the bar and practice of law of Ukraine (D. MERIDOR)

CDL-REF(2011)043 English 17/08/2011 - Public
Draft law on amendments to the law on the judiciary and the status of judges and to other legal acts of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2011)037 English 12/08/2011 - Public
Draft Law on Freedom of Peaceful Assembly of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2011)040 English 22/07/2011 - Public
Draft law of Ukraine on the bar and practice of law

CDL-REF(2011)034 English 28/06/2011 - Public
Draft Law on the election of members of Parliament of Ukraine

CDL(2011)015 English 11/03/2011 - Public
Draft Opinion on the concept paper on the establishment and functioning of a constitutional assembly of Ukraine (K. TUORI, E. TANCHEV, F. SEJERSTED)

CDL(2011)010 English 11/03/2011 - Public
Draft Opinion on the draft law on languages in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, J. VELAERS, M. Galdia)

CDL-REF(2011)012 English 03/03/2011 - Public
Concept paper for the establishment and functioning of a constitutional assembly of Ukraine

CDL-REF(2011)001 English 07/01/2011 - Public
Draft law on languages in Ukraine and explanatoy note and comparative table

CDL-EL(2010)034 English 14/12/2010 - Public
Draft election code of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine

CDL(2010)126 English 10/12/2010 - Public
Draft opinion on the constitutional situation in Ukraine (K. TUORI, D. MAUS, G. PAPUASHVILI, E. TANCHEV, A. NUSSBERGER)

CDL-EL(2010)033 English 10/12/2010 - Public
Draft opinion on the draft election code of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (S. DARMANOVIĆ, N. EȘANU)

CDL(2010)116 English 18/11/2010 - Public
Judgement of the constitutional court of Ukraine - 30 September 2010

CDL(2010)097 English 11/10/2010 - Public
Draft joint opinion on the law on the judicial system and the status of judges of Ukraine by the Venice Commission and the Directorate of Co-operation within the Directorate General of Human Rights and Legal Affairs of the Council of Europe (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, S. Gass, P. Lemmens)

CDL(2010)099 English 08/10/2010 - Public
Draft joint opinion on the law on peaceful assemblies of Ukraine by the Venice Commission and OSCE/ODHIR (C. GRABENWARTER, J. HAMILTON, N. VULCHANOV, F. FLANAGAN, H. HAENEL, D. Goldenberger)

CDL(2010)098 English 07/10/2010 - Public
Draft joint opinion on the law amending certain legislative acts of Ukraine in relation to the prevention of abuse of the right to appeal by the Venice Commission and the Directorate of Co-operation within the Directorate General of Human Rights and Legal Affairs of the Council of Europe (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, L. Bachmaier, S. Gass)

CDL(2010)086 English 24/09/2010 - Public
Comments on the Law of Ukraine on Amending certain legislative acts of Ukraine in relation to prevention of abuse of the right to appeal (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2010)085 English 24/09/2010 - Public
Comments on the Law of Ukraine on Amending certain legislative acts of Ukraine in relation to prevention of abuse of the right to appeal (J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2010)084 English 24/09/2010 - Public
Law of Ukraine N° 2453-VI on the Judiciary and the Status of Judges adopted by the Verkhnova Rada on 7 July 2010

CDL(2010)081 English 22/09/2010 - Public
Draft Law on Peaceful Assemblies of Ukraine

CDL(2010)068 English 02/07/2010 - Public
Explanatory Note to the Draft Law of Ukraine on amending certain laws of Ukraine regarding prevention of abuse of the right to appeal

CDL(2010)067 English 02/07/2010 - Public
Draft Law of Ukraine on amending certain legislative acts of Ukraine in relation to prevention of abuse of the right to appeal

CDL(2010)066 English 02/07/2010 - Public
Explanatory Note of the Draft Law of Ukraine on the Judiciary and the Status of Judges

CDL(2010)064 English 02/07/2010 - Public
Draft Law of Ukraine on the Judiciary and the Status of Judges

CDL(2010)065 English 30/06/2010 - Public
Preliminary Comments on the Draft Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2010)063 English 30/06/2010 - Public
Preliminary Comments on the Draft Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges of Ukraine (J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2010)028 English 05/03/2010 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on the Draft Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judge of Ukraine by the Venice Commission and the Directorate of Co-operation within the Directorate General of Human Rights and Legal Affairs of the Council of Europe on the basis of comments by (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, S. Gass, M. Pellonpaa)

CDL(2009)175 English 04/12/2009 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on the order of organising and conducting peaceful events of Ukraine by the Venice Commission and OSCE/ODIHR (C. GRABENWARTER, F. FLANAGAN, H. HAENEL)

CDL(2009)165 English 06/11/2009 - Public
Draft Law on order of organising and conducting peaceful events of Ukraine

CDL-EL(2009)016 English 01/10/2009 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on the Law on Amending some legislative acts on the Election of the President of Ukraine adopted by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on 24 July 2009 by the Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR (J. PILGRIM, A. NUSSBERGER)

CDL(2009)156 English 30/09/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2009)155 English 30/09/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges of Ukraine (J. HAMILTON)

CDL-EL(2009)023 English 24/09/2009 - Public
Law on the Elections of the President of Ukraine

CDL(2009)111 English 21/09/2009 - Public
Draft Law on the Judicial System and the Status of Judges of Ukraine

CDL-EL(2009)014 English 03/09/2009 - Public
Law on amending some legislative acts on elections of the President of Ukraine (adopted by the Parliament of Ukraine on 24 July 2009)

CDL(2009)100 English 08/07/2009 - Public
Preliminary Opinion on the Draft Law of Ukraine on the Office of the Public Prosecutor (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2009)107 English 02/07/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of Ukraine on the Prosecution Service (No. 2491) submitted to Parliament by People's Deputies V. Shvets, Yu. Prokopchuk, V. Sivkovych et al. (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2009)106 English 02/07/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of Ukraine on the Prosecution Service (No. 2491) submitted to Parliament by People's Deputies V. Shvets, Yu. Prokopchuk, V. Sivkovych et al. (J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2009)098 English 05/06/2009 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law of Ukraine amending the Constitution presented by the President of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, A. NUSSBERGER, G. Marcou)

CDL-EL(2009)008 English 05/06/2009 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on the Draft Law NO. 3366 about Elections to the Parliament of Ukraine by the Venice Commission and the OSCE/ODIHR (J. PILGRIM, C. CLOSA MONTERO)

CDL(2009)096 English 03/06/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of Ukraine amending the Constitution presented by the President of Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2009)097 English 02/06/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of Ukraine amending the Constitution presented by the President of Ukraine (G. Marcou)

CDL(2009)095 English 02/06/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of Ukraine ameding the Constitution presented by the President of Ukraine (K. TUORI)

CDL(2009)094 English 02/06/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of Ukraine ameding the Constitution presented by the President of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2009)093 English 02/06/2009 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of Ukraine ameding the Constitution presented by the President of Ukraine (A. NUSSBERGER)

CDL(2009)085 English 26/05/2009 - Public
Draft Law of Ukraine on the Office of the Public Prosecutor - Draft No. 2491 adopted in First Reading on 14 March 2009 by Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine

CDL(2009)084 English 26/05/2009 - Public
Draft Law about elections to the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (Registration No. 3366 as of 13.11.2008)

CDL(2009)068 English 16/04/2009 - Public
Draft law on amending the Consitution of Ukraine presented by the President of Ukraine

CDL(2009)068add English 16/04/2009 - Public
Explanatory note to the draft Law on amending the Constitution of Ukraine

CDL(2009)034 English 05/03/2009 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law amending the Constitution of Ukraine presented by People's Deputies Yanukovych, Lavrynovych, et al. (H. SUCHOCKA, P. PACZOLAY, A. NUSSBERGER)

CDL(2009)021 English 05/03/2009 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law amending the Law on Election of People's Deputies of Ukraine presented by People's Deputies Lavrynovych and Portnov (P. PACZOLAY, A. NUSSBERGER)

CDL(2009)016 English 20/02/2009 - Public
Draft Law of Ukraine amending the Law on Election of People's Deputies of Ukraine - Draft Initiated by People’s Deputies of Ukraine A. Portnov and O. V. Lavrynovych

CDL(2009)015 English 20/02/2009 - Public
Draft Law of Ukraine amending the Constitution of Ukraine - Draft Initiated by People’s Deputies of Ukraine V. F. Yanukovych, O. V. Lavrynovych et al.

CDL-EL(2008)028 English 08/12/2008 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the All-Ukrainian Referendum by Mr O. Lavrynovych (Member of Parliament of Ukraine) (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL-EL(2008)023 English 05/12/2008 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the all-Ukrainian Referendum by Mr O. Lavrynovych (Member of Parliament of Ukraine) (A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO)

CDL-EL(2008)025 English 25/11/2008 - Public
Draft Law on the All-Ukrainian Referendum by Mr O. Lavrynovych (Member of Parliament of Ukraine)

CDL(2008)072 English 06/06/2008 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Constitution of Ukraine prepared by a Working Group headed by Mr V.M. Shapoval (H. SUCHOCKA, S. BARTOLE, K. TUORI, P. PACZOLAY, A. NUSSBERGER)

CDL(2008)067 English 05/06/2008 - Public
Comments on the Draft Constitution of Ukraine prepared by a Working Group headed by Mr V.M. Shapoval (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2008)066 English 04/06/2008 - Public
Comments on the Draft Constitution of Ukraine prepared by a Working Group headed by Mr V.M. Shapoval (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL-EL(2008)010 English 03/06/2008 - Public
Comments ont the Draft Laws on the All-Ukrainian Referendum and on Local Referendum of Ukraine (A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO)

CDL-EL(2008)009 English 27/05/2008 - Public
Draft Laws on the All-Ukrainian Referendum and on Local Referendum of Ukraine

CDL(2008)054 English 26/05/2008 - Public
Comments on the Draft Constitution of Ukraine prepared by a Working Group headed by Mr V.M. Shapoval (A. NUSSBERGER)

CDL(2008)053 English 26/05/2008 - Public
Comments on the Draft Constitution of Ukraine prepared by a Working Group headed by Mr V.M. Shapoval (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(2008)052 English 26/05/2008 - Public
Comments on the Draft Constitution of Ukraine prepared by a Working Group headed by Mr V.M. Shapoval (K. TUORI)

CDL(2008)046 English 28/04/2008 - Public
Draft Constitution of Ukraine

CDL-EL(2007)040 English 15/11/2007 - Public
Seminar for judges dealing with electoral disputes (Kyiv (Ukraine), 14 - 15 September 2007) Report "The scope of protection of electoral rights under Article 3 of Protocol No.1" (G. Badashvili)

CDL-EL(2007)039 French 15/11/2007 - Public
Séminaire pour les juges en charge du contentieux électoral (Kiev (Ukraine), 14 - 15 septembre 2007) Rapport "Approche et traitement du contention de l'élection" (D. VINOLAS)

CDL-EL(2007)038 English 15/11/2007 - Public
Seminar for judges dealing with electoral disputes (Kyiv (Ukraine), 14 - 15 September 2007) Report: Venice Commission's opinions on Ukrainian legislation on elections and the judiciary (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)084 English 24/09/2007 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Amendments to the Law on the Status of People's Deputy in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)072 English 29/08/2007 - Public
Law on the adoption of Amendments to the Law on the Election of People's Deputies and some other Legislative Acts of Ukraine

CDL(2007)071 English 21/08/2007 - Public
Draft Amendments to the Law on the Status of People's Deputy in Ukraine

CDL(2007)070 English 10/08/2007 - Public
Comments on the Draft Amendments to the Law on the Status of People's Deputies of Ukraine (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(2007)069 English 10/08/2007 - Public
Comments on the Draft Amendments to the Law on the Status of People's Deputies of Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)047 English 29/05/2007 - Public
Draft Opinion on legislative provisions concerning early elections in Ukraine (A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO)

CDL(2007)062 English 25/05/2007 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on the Parliamentary Opposition in Ukraine

CDL(2007)045 English 23/05/2007 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on the Draft Law on State Register of Voters of Ukraine by the Venice Commission and the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (OSCE/ODIHR) (A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO, J. Middleton)

CDL(2007)026rev English 22/05/2007 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Law on Amendments to the Legislation concerning the Status of Deputies of the Verkhovna Rada of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea and of Local Councils in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)056 English 14/05/2007 - Public
Information on the Draft Law on Parliamentary Opposition and Other Legislation in Ukraine (N. I Petrova)

CDL(2007)044 English 07/05/2007 - Public
Draft Law on State Register of Voters of Ukraine

CDL(2007)033rev English 23/03/2007 - Public
Draft Preliminary Opinion on the Draft Law on the Parliamentary Opposition in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)038 English 12/03/2007 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on the Judiciary and the Draft Law on the Status of Judges of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, G. Oberto, A. Zalar)

CDL(2007)033 English 08/03/2007 - Public
Draft Preliminary Opinion on the Draft Law on the Parliamentary Opposition in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)029 English 07/03/2007 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Parliamentary Opposition in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(2007)028 English 07/03/2007 - Public
Comments on the Law on Amendments to the Legislation concerning the Status of Deputies of the Verkhovna Rada of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea and of Local Councils in Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)027 English 07/03/2007 - Public
Comments on the Law on Amendments to the Legislation concerning the Status of Deputies of the Verkhovna Rada of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea and of Local Councils in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(2007)026 English 07/03/2007 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Law on Amendments to the Legislation concerning the Status of Deputies of the Verkhovna Rada of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea and of Local Councils in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)025 English 07/03/2007 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Parliamentary Opposition in Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY)

CDL(2007)040 English 06/03/2007 - Public
Draft Law on the Judiciary of Ukraine (Comparative table showing amendments to the draft)

CDL(2007)039 English 06/03/2007 - Public
Draft Law on the Status of Judges of Ukraine (Comparative table showing amendments to the draft)

CDL(2007)035 English 06/03/2007 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the Judiciary and the Draft Law on the Status of Judges of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2007)034 English 06/03/2007 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the Judiciary and the Draft Law on the Status of Judges of Ukraine (J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2007)006 English 08/02/2007 - Public
Draft Law on the Parliamentary Opposition in Ukraine

CDL(2007)003 English 01/02/2007 - Public
Law on Amendments to certain laws concerning the Status of Deputies of the Verkhova Rada of the Authonomous Republic of Crimea and Local Councils of Ukraine

CDL(2006)107 English 07/12/2006 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the Cabinet of Ministers and Central Public Executive Authorities of Ukraine (K. TUORI)

CDL(2006)099 English 04/12/2006 - Public
Draft Law on the Cabinet of Ministers and Central Public Executive Authorities of Ukraine

CDL(2006)097 English 04/12/2006 - Public
Draft Law on the Status of Judges of Ukraine

CDL(2006)096 English 04/12/2006 - Public
Draft Law on the Judiciary of Ukraine

CDL(2006)072 English 09/10/2006 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on the Insertion of Amendments on Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organisations in Ukraine (G. MALINVERNI, L. CHRISTIANS)

CDL(2006)073 English 06/10/2006 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law of Ukraine amending the Constitutional Provisions on the Procuracy (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON, P. Cornu)

CDL(2006)057 English 04/10/2006 - Public
Draft Opinion on the entitlement for former MP's to resume their parliamentary seat upon ceasing their governmental functions in Ukraine (J. SCHOLSEM, K. TUORI)

CDL(2006)071 English 03/10/2006 - Public
Joint Opinion on the Draft Law on Peaceful Assemblies of Ukraine (C. GRABENWARTER, G. MALINVERNI, H. HAENEL, D. Goldberger)

CDL(2006)070 English 03/10/2006 - Public
Constitution of Ukraine, as of 25 May 2006

CDL(2006)069 English 27/09/2006 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (J. SCHOLSEM, K. TUORI)

CDL(2006)063 English 14/09/2006 - Public
Draft Law on Peaceful Assemblies in Ukraine

CDL(2006)062 English 13/09/2006 - Public
Draft Law on the Insertion of Amendments on Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organisations in Ukraine

CDL(2006)060 English 05/09/2006 - Public
Draft Law on the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine

CDL(2006)032 English 17/06/2006 - Public
Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine prepared by the Prosecutor General’s Office

CDL(2006)041 English 06/06/2006 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine concerning the Prokuratura (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2006)049 English 02/06/2006 - Public
Draft Opinion on possible Constitutional and Legislative Improvements to ensure the uninterrupted functioning of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (P. PACZOLAY, J. MAZAK, A. ENDZIŅŠ)

CDL(2006)042 English 02/06/2006 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine concerning the Prokuratura (J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2006)044 English 31/05/2006 - Public
Comments on Possible Constitutional and Legislative Improvements to ensure the Uniterrupted Functioning of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (J. MAZAK)

CDL(2006)040 French 31/05/2006 - Public
Observations sur le projet de loi sur les amendements à la Constitution de l'Ukraine relatifs à la Prokuratura (P. Cornu)

CDL(2006)038 English 29/05/2006 - Public
Information on the (in)compatibility of the mandate of a member of parliament and the office of Cabinet Minister according to the Swedish Constitution (H. VOGEL)

CDL(2006)037 French 24/05/2006 - Public
Observations sur la possibilité d'introduire le droit pour les anciens membres du gouvernement de reprendre leur siège au parlement en Ukraine (J. SCHOLSEM)

CDL(2006)036 English 24/05/2006 - Public
Comments on the possible introduction of the entitlement for former government members to resume their parliamentary seat in Ukraine (K. TUORI)

CDL-EL(2005)056 English 08/12/2005 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on the Draft Law on the State Register of Voters of Ukraine, submitted by people’s Deputies of Ukraine, Mr O. Zadorozhny and Mr Yu. Klyuchkovsky (A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO, J. Middleton)

CDL-EL(2005)055 English 08/12/2005 - Public
Draft Joint Opinion on the Law on Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine (A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO, T. ANNUS, J. PILGRIM, J. Middleton)

CDL-EL(2005)054 English 24/11/2005 - Public
Law on making Amendments to the Law on Election of People's Deputies of Ukraine (7 July 2005)

CDL-EL(2005)046 English 17/10/2005 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Election of People's Deputies of Ukraine adopted on 7 July 2005 (T. ANNUS)

CDL-EL(2005)045 English 17/10/2005 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Election of People's Deputies of Ukraine adopted on 7 July 2005 and on the Draft Law on the State Register of Voters of Ukraine submitted by people’s Deputies of Ukraine, Mr O. Zadorozhny and Mr Yu. Klyuchkovsky (A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO)

CDL(2005)046 English 03/06/2005 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine as adopted on 8 December 2004 (S. BARTOLE, K. TUORI)

CDL-EL(2005)022 English 02/06/2005 - Public
Law on State Register of Voters of Ukraine

CDL-EL(2005)021 English 02/06/2005 - Public
Law on Parliamentary Elections of Ukraine

CDL-EL(2005)002 Engl./Fr. 30/05/2005 - Public
Electoral Training Workshops: Baku, Azerbaijan, 8-10 July 2004 - Donezk, Ukraine, 13-14 September 2004 - Kherson, Ukraine, 16-17 September 2004 - Chisinau, Moldova, 10-11 December 2004: Reports

CDL(2005)036 English 25/04/2005 - Public
Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine adopted on 8 December 2004

CDL(2005)032 English 08/03/2005 - Public
Observations on the National Strategy for the Reform of the Territorial Organisation System of the Authorities in Ukraine (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(2005)031 French 01/03/2005 - Public
Observations sur le projet de stratégie nationale pour la réforme du système d'organisation territoriale des autorités en Ukraine

CDL(2005)030 English 01/03/2005 - Public
Observations on the Draft National Strategy on the Reform of the Territorial Organization System of the Authorities in Ukraine (K. LAPINSKAS)

CDL(2005)029 English 01/03/2005 - Public
Draft National Strategy on the Reform of the Territorial Organization System of the Authorities in Ukraine

CDL-EL(2004)017syn English 12/10/2004 - Public
Electoral Training Workshops (Donezk, Ukraine, 13 – 14 September 2004 and Kherson, Ukraine, 16 – 17 September 2004): Synopsis

CDL-EL(2004)017syn French 12/10/2004 - Public
Ateliers de formation électorale (Donetsk, Ukraine, 13 – 14 septembre 2004 et Kherson, Ukraine, 16 – 17 septembre 2004): Carnet de bord

CDL(2004)083 French 04/10/2004 - Public
Projet d'avis concernant le projet de loi amendant la loi de la République d'Ukraine sur le Ministère public (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2004)096 English 30/09/2004 - Public
Comments on the procedure of amending the Constitution of Ukraine (H. KJERULF THORGEIRSDOTTIR)

CDL(2004)099 English 27/09/2004 - Public
Comments on the procedure of amending the Constitution of Ukraine (K. TUORI)

CDL(2004)094 English 27/09/2004 - Public
Draft Opinion on the procedure of amending the Constitution of Ukraine (K. TUORI, H. KJERULF THORGEIRSDOTTIR, F. FLANAGAN)

CDL(2004)081 English 27/09/2004 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the Status of Indigenous Peoples of Ukraine (M. LAZAROVA TRAJKOVSKA)

CDL(2004)080 English 27/09/2004 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the Status of Indigenous Peoples of Ukraine (P. VAN DIJK)

CDL(2004)079 English 27/09/2004 - Public
Draft Law on the Status of Indigenous Peoples of Ukraine

CDL(2004)095 English 23/09/2004 - Public
Comments on the procedure of amending the Constitution of Ukraine (F. FLANAGAN)

CDL(2004)082 English 22/09/2004 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on the Status of Indigenous Peoples of Ukraine (P. VAN DIJK, M. LAZAROVA TRAJKOVSKA)

CDL(2004)083 English 20/09/2004 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law amending the Law of Ukraine on the Office of the Public Prosecutor (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2004)060fin English 21/06/2004 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of the Republic of Ukraine on the Public Prosecutor's Orrice endorsed by the Venice Commission at its 59th Plenary Session (Venice, 18-19 June 2004) (J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2004)048fin English 21/06/2004 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of the Republic of Ukraine on the Public Prosecutor's Office endorsed by the Venice Commission at its 59th Plenary Session (Venice, 18-19 June 2004) (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2004)065 English 15/06/2004 - Public
Draft Opinion on the latest version of the Draft Law amending the Law on National Minorities in Ukraine (F. MATSCHER)

CDL(2004)060 English 10/06/2004 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of the Republic of Ukraine on the Public Prosecutor's Office (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2004)060 French 10/06/2004 - Public
Observations concernant le projet de loi de la République d'Ukraine sur le Ministère Public (H. SUCHOCKA, J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2004)066 English 08/06/2004 - Public
Revised Draft Law amending the Law "on National Minorities" of Ukraine (May 2004)

CDL(2004)052 English 03/06/2004 - Public
Draft Law of the Republic of Ukraine on the Public Prosecutor's Office

CDL(2004)051 English 03/06/2004 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on the conception of the State Ethnic Policy of Ukraine (P. VAN DIJK)

CDL(2004)050 English 03/06/2004 - Public
Draft Law on the Conception of the State Ethnic Policy of Ukraine

CDL(2004)048 French 03/06/2004 - Public
Observations concernant le projet de loi de la République d'Ukraine sur le Ministère public (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2004)048 English 03/06/2004 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law of the Republic of Ukraine on the Public Prosecutor's Office (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2004)002 French 26/01/2004 - Public
Projet d'avis sur deux projets de loi modifiant la loi sur les minorités nationales en Ukraine (F. MATSCHER)

CDL(2004)002 English 26/01/2004 - Public
Draft Opinion on Two Draft Laws amending the Law on National Minorities in Ukraine (F. MATSCHER)

CDL(2003)087 English 20/12/2003 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Election of People's Deputies of Ukraine (II) Draft introduced by people’s deputies S. Havrysh, Y. Ioffe and H. Dashutin (A. SANCHEZ NAVARRO)

CDL(2003)093 English 08/12/2003 - Public
Draft Opinion on Three Draft Laws proposing amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, K. TUORI, H. KJERULF THORGEIRSDOTTIR, F. FLANAGAN)

CDL(2003)098 English 04/12/2003 - Public
Comments on the three Draft Laws proposing amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(2003)097 English 03/12/2003 - Public
Comments on the Draft Laws amending the Law on National Minorities in Ukraine (F. MATSCHER)

CDL(2003)096 English 03/12/2003 - Public
Comments on the three Draft Laws proposing amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (H. KJERULF THORGEIRSDOTTIR)

CDL(2003)095 English 03/12/2003 - Public
Comments on the three Draft Laws proposing amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (K. TUORI)

CDL(2003)094 English 03/12/2003 - Public
Comments on the three Draft Laws proposing amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (F. FLANAGAN)

CDL(2003)089 English 27/11/2003 - Public
Second Draft Law amending the Law on National Minorities in Ukraine and Explanatory Memorandum

CDL(2003)088 English 27/11/2003 - Public
First Draft Law amending the Law on National Minorities in Ukraine

CDL(2003)066 English 25/11/2003 - Public
Law of Ukraine "on Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine” amended according to the Law no. 2977-III (297-14) of 17 January 2002

CDL(2003)086 English 19/11/2003 - Public
Constitution of Ukraine adopted by the Fifth Session of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on 28 June 1996.

CDL(2003)084 English 17/11/2003 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Election of People's Deputies of Ukraine (I) Draft introduced by people’s deputies M. Rud'kowsky and V. Melnychuk (K. VOLLAN)

CDL(2003)083 English 17/11/2003 - Public
Draft Law on Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine (I) - Draft introduced by people’s deputies of Ukraine: M. Rud’kowsky and V. Melnychuk

CDL(2003)082 English 14/11/2003 - Public
Draft Law on Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine (II) - Draft introduced by people’s deputies of Ukraine: S. Havrysh, Y. Ioffe and H. Dashutin

CDL(2003)081 English 13/11/2003 - Public
3rd Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (Registration number 4180 - 19 September 2003)

CDL(2003)080 English 13/11/2003 - Public
2nd Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (Registration number 4105 - 4 September 2003)

CDL(2003)079 English 13/11/2003 - Public
1st Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (Registration number 3207-1 - 1 July 2003)

CDL(2003)033 French 26/06/2003 - Public
Observations sur le projet de loi sur les amendements à la Constitution de l'Ukraine (G. BATLINER)

CDL(2003)031 English 26/06/2003 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (K. TUORI)

CDL(2003)041 English 06/06/2003 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (S. BARTOLE, K. TUORI, G. BATLINER, F. FLANAGAN)

CDL(2003)035 English 27/05/2003 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine (F. FLANAGAN)

CDL(2003)034 English 27/05/2003 - Public
Comments on the Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine

CDL(2003)032 English 14/04/2003 - Public
Draft Law on Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine as prepared by the President and submitted to nation-wide discussion on 6 March 2003

CDL(2003)027 English 07/03/2003 - Public
Information Document concerning the Visit of the Rapporteurs of the Venice Commission to Ukraine on 25-26 February 2003

CDL(2002)104 English 28/06/2002 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Ukrainian Legislation on Political Parties (V. STOICA)

CDL(2002)101 English 27/06/2002 - Public
Legislation on Political Parties - General Remarks with Regard to the Projects concerning Armenian and Ukrainian Drafts

CDL(2002)042 English 05/03/2002 - Public
Comments on the Law on Political Parties of Ukraine and Draft Bill on Incorporation of Amendments into Certain Legislative Acts

CDL(2002)037 English 01/03/2002 - Public
Comments on the Law on Political Parties of Ukraine and Draft Bill on Incorporation of Amendments into Certain Legislative Acts (H. VOGEL)

CDL(2002)036 English 01/03/2002 - Public
Law on Political Parties of Ukraine and Draft Bill on Incorporation of Amendments into Certain Legislative Acts

CDL(2002)036rev English 01/03/2002 - Public
Law on political parties of Ukraine and draft bill in incorportation of amendments into certainlegislative acts

CDL(2002)012 English 27/02/2002 - Public
Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on Principles of the State Policy of Ukraine in the Sphere of Human Rights

CDL(2002)011 English 19/02/2002 - Public
Draft Opinion on the Resolution on the Principles of the State Policy of Ukraine in the Sphere of Human Rights, adopted by the Vekhovna Rada of Ukraine on 17 June 1999 (G. BATLINER)

CDL(2002)011 French 19/02/2002 - Public
Projet d'avis sur la résolution sur les principes de la politique de l'état d'Ukraine dans le domaine des droits de l'homme, adoptée le 17 juin 1999 par la Verkhovna Rada d'Ukraine (G. BATLINER)

CDL(2001)134 English 11/12/2001 - Public
Opinion on the present law and on the draft law of Ukraine on the Public Prosecutor’s Office (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2001)128 English 07/12/2001 - Public
Opinion on the present law and on the draft law of Ukraine on the Public Prosecutor’s Office (J. HAMILTON)

CDL(2001)125 English 07/12/2001 - Public
Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada on Principles of the State Policy of Ukraine in the Sphere of Human Rights

CDL(2001)120 English 29/11/2001 - Public
Law of Ukraine on Introduction of Amendments to the Law "On Public Prosecutor's Office"

CDL(2001)119 English 29/11/2001 - Public
Law of Ukraine on the Public Prosecutor's Office

CDL(2001)107 English 15/10/2001 - Public
Ukraine: Preliminary Comments on the Law on Elections of People's Deputies, adopted by the Verkhovna Rada on 13 September 2001 prepared in co-operation with the Secretariat of the Commission (G. NOLTE)

CDL(2001)092 English 05/10/2001 - Public
Draft Law on Elections adopted by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on 13 September 2001

CDL(2001)078 English 03/07/2001 - Public
Opinion on the Draft Law of Ukraine “On the Judicial System” (J. SAID PULLICINO, A. ELLUL)

CDL(2001)059 English 22/06/2001 - Public
Concept of the State Ethnic and National policy of Ukraine (F. MATSCHER)

CDL(2001)055 English 14/06/2001 - Public
Opinion on Draft Law of Ukraine on the "Judicial System" (CDL (2001) 46) (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(2001)054 English 13/06/2001 - Public
Thel Law of Ukraine "On Introducing Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine": Draft Proposed by National Deputies of Ukraine

CDL(2001)051 English 08/06/2001 - Public
Consolidated Opinion on the Ukraine Constitutional Reform Project

CDL(2001)051 French 08/06/2001 - Public
Avis consolidé sur le Projet de réforme constitutionnelle de l'Ukraine

CDL(2001)046 English 28/05/2001 - Public
The Law of Ukraine - Judicial System

CDL(2001)042 English 10/05/2001 - Public
Concept of the State Ethnic and National Policy of Ukraine

CDL(2000)089 Engl./Fr. 06/12/2000 - Public
Replies to the questionnaire on the execution of constitutional review decisions / Réponses au questionnaire sur l’exécution des arrêts des juridictions constitutionnelles

CDL-JU(2000)039 French 04/10/2000 - Public
Description de la Cour constitutionnelle d’Ukraine ainsi que des décisions abrégées publiées dans le Bulletin de jurisprudence constitutionnelle

CDL-JU(2000)039 English 04/10/2000 - Public
Description of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine as well as précis published in the Bulletin on Constitutional Case-Law

CDL(2000)073 English 27/09/2000 - Public
Draft opinion on the implementation of the referendum in Ukraine (G. MALINVERNI, S. BARTOLE, G. BATLINER)

CDL(2000)073 French 27/09/2000 - Public
Projet d’avis sur la mise en œuvre du référendum en Ukraine (G. MALINVERNI, S. BARTOLE, G. BATLINER)

CDL(2000)072 English 26/09/2000 - Public
Conclusion of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine Case of the Introduction of Amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine on the Initiative of People’s Deputies of Ukraine

CDL(2000)042 English 06/06/2000 - Public
Law on Amending the Constitution of Ukraine in Compliance with the Results of the All-Ukrainian Referendum of 16 April 2000 (Submitted by 152 national deputies of Ukraine)

CDL(2000)041 English 06/06/2000 - Public
Law on Amending the Constitution of Ukraine in Compliance with the Results of the All-Ukrainian Referendum on Popular Initiative (Submitted by the President of Ukraine)

CDL(2000)014rev English 31/03/2000 - Public
Constitutional Referendum in Ukraine. Opinion adopted by the Commission at its 42nd Plenary session (Venice, 31 March 2000) (H. STEINBERGER, G. MALINVERNI, S. BARTOLE, G. BATLINER, C. SVOBODA)

CDL(2000)014rev French 31/03/2000 - Public
Référendum constitutionnel en Ukraine. Avis adopté par la Commision lors de sa 42e réunion plénière (Venise, 31 mars 2000) (H. STEINBERGER, G. MALINVERNI, S. BARTOLE, G. BATLINER, C. SVOBODA)

CDL(2000)014 English 17/03/2000 - Public
Constitutional referendum in Ukraine: Draft consolidated opinion prepared by the secretariat based on individual opinions (H. STEINBERGER, G. MALINVERNI, S. BARTOLE, G. BATLINER, C. SVOBODA)

CDL(2000)011 English 17/03/2000 - Public
Constitutional referendum in Ukraine: Individual opinion (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(2000)010 English 14/03/2000 - Public
Constitutional referendum in Ukraine: Individual opinion (C. SVOBODA)

CDL(2000)009 English 14/03/2000 - Public
Constitutional referendum in Ukraine: Individual opinion (H. STEINBERGER)

CDL(2000)008 French 14/03/2000 - Public
Référendum constitutionnel en Ukraine: Observations individuelles (G. MALINVERNI)

CDL(2000)007 French 14/03/2000 - Public
Référendum constitutionnel en Ukraine: Observations individuelles (G. BATLINER)

CDL(2000)004rev English 13/03/2000 - Public
Decree of the President of Ukraine on announcement of the all - Ukraine referendum on the people's initiative

CDL(2000)004 English 01/02/2000 - Public
Decree of the President of Ukraine on announcement of the all-Ukraine referendum on the people's initiative

CDL(2000)002 English 18/01/2000 - Public
The law on the elections of people’ deputies of Ukraine: an assessment from a comparative perspective (M. KRENNERICH)

CDL(1999)089 English 04/01/2000 - Public
Opinion on the draft law of Ukraine on the judicial system (H. SUCHOCKA, H. TORFASON, J. SAID PULLICINO)

CDL(1999)087 English 07/12/1999 - Public
Opinion on a proposed law on the judiciary of Ukraine (H. TORFASON)

CDL(1999)086 English 07/12/1999 - Public
Draft law of Ukraine on the judiciary (J. SAID PULLICINO)

CDL(1999)051 English 30/09/1999 - Public
The 1998 parliamentary electoral law of Ukraine: evaluative considerations from a comparative perspective (F. GROTZ)

CDL(1999)045 English 20/09/1999 - Public
Law on elections of people's deputies of Ukraine

CDL-UE(1999)002 Engl./Fr. 05/02/1999 - Public
Réponse au questionnaire : droit consitutionnel et intégration européenne par les Etats non membres de l'Union européenne : Albanie, Bulgarie, Croatia, Czech Republic, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Romania, Ukraine

CDL(1999)064 English 01/01/1999 - Public
Law of Ukraine on the Judicial System

CDL-JU(1998)025 English 28/05/1998 - Public
Workshop on "Principles of constitutional control, techniques of constitutional and statutory interpretation" (Kyiv, 5-6 June 1998): Report on "Remarks on the Ukrainien Constitutional Provisions Concerning the Constitutional Court, with a Brief Summary of the Italian Experience" (C. PINELLI)

CDL(1998)038 French 11/05/1998 - Public
Avis sur le concept de la réforme des organes centraux du pouvoir exécutif en Ukraine (J. ROBERT)

CDL(1998)007 French 17/02/1998 - Public
Observations sur les conséquences juridiques qu'entraîne pour les Etats, la double ratification de la Convention européenne des Droits de l'Homme et de la Convention des Droits de l'Homme et des Libertés (S. HOLOVATY)

CDL(1998)007 English 17/02/1998 - Public
Comments on the legal implications for states ratifying both the European Convention of Human Rights and the Human Convention of the Commonwealth of Independent States (S. HOLOVATY)

CDL-JU(1998)032 English 01/01/1998 - Public
"General concepts of implementation of international law" (G. MAAS GEESTERANUS)

CDL(1998)031 French 01/01/1998 - Public
Concept de la réforme des organes centraux du pouvoir exécutif en Ukraine

CDL(1997)001 French 06/01/1997 - Public
Projet d'avis sur la Constitution de l'Ukraine

CDL(1997)001 English 06/01/1997 - Public
Draft opinion on the Constitution of Ukraine

CDL(1997)065 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Comments on the constitutional issues which might be raised by the death penalty in Ukraine in the light of the Constitution of 28 June 1996 (S. HOLOVATY)

CDL(1997)051 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Draft opinion of the Venice Commission on the constitutional aspects of the death penalty in Ukraine

CDL(1997)051 French 01/01/1997 - Public
Projet d'avis de la Commission de Venise sur les aspects constitutionnels de la peine de mort en Ukraine

CDL(1997)033 French 01/01/1997 - Public
Brefs commentaires sur le problème de la licéité de la peine de mort en Ukraine selon la Constitution du 28 juin 1996 (G. MALINVERNI)

CDL(1997)032 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Comments on the constitutional issues which might be raised by the death penalty in Ukraine in the light of the Constitution of 26.06.1996 (J. HELGESEN)

CDL(1997)031 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Comments on the constitutional issues which might be raised by the death penalty in Ukraine in the light of the Constitution of 26.06.1996 (J. KLUCKA)

CDL(1997)018 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Draft opinion on the law on the Constitutional Court of Ukraine adopted at the 31st plenary meeting of the Commission: Secretariat Memorandum

CDL(1997)018 French 01/01/1997 - Public
Avis relatif à la loi sur la Cour constitutionnelle de l'Ukraine adopté lors de la 31ème réunion plénière de la Commission: Note du Secrétariat

CDL(1997)015 French 01/01/1997 - Public
Commentaires sur les questions constitutionnelles que la peine de mort en Ukraine pourrait susciter d'après sa Constitution du 28 juin 1996 (G. BATLINER)

CDL(1997)015 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Comments on the constitutional issues which might be raised by the death penalty in Ukraine in the light of the Constitution of 28 June 1996 (G. BATLINER)

CDL(1997)010 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Comments on the law of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (S. HOLOVATY)

CDL(1997)004 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Comments on the law on the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (S. BARTOLE)

CDL-MIN(1997)001 English 01/01/1997 - Public
Replies to the questionnaire on the participation of members of minorities in public life

CDL(1997)018rev English 01/01/1997 - Public
Opinion on the law on the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, adopted at the 31st plenary meeting of the Commission (S. BARTOLE, J. KLUCKA)

CDL(1997)018rev French 01/01/1997 - Public
Avis relatif à la loi sur la Cour constitutionnelle de l'Ukraine adopté lors de la 31ème réunion plénière de la Commission (S. BARTOLE, J. KLUCKA)

CDL(1997)005rev English 01/01/1997 - Public
Comments on the law on the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (J. KLUCKA)

CDL(1996)079 English 16/10/1996 - Public
Opinion on the provisions concerning the organisation and status of local and regional authorities under the new Constitution of Ukraine (adopted on 28 June 1996) (A. DELCAMP)

CDL(1996)079 French 16/10/1996 - Public
Avis sur les dispositions concernant l'organisation et le statut des pouvoirs locaux et régionaux de la nouvelle Constitution de l'Ukraine adoptée le 28.06.1996 (A. DELCAMP)

CDL(1996)020 English 10/05/1996 - Public
Opinion on the draft Constitution of Ukraine: (text approved by the Constitutional Commission on 11 March 1996 (CDL (96) 15): adopted at the 27the Meeting of the Venice Commission on 17-18 May 1996 (A. MILENKOVA, H. STEINBERGER, S. BARTOLE, L. AGUIAR DE LUQUE, J. KLUCKA, G. BATLINER, C. SVOBODA)

CDL(1996)020rev English 10/05/1996 - Public
Opinion on the Draft Constitution of Ukraine (text approved by the Constitutional Commission on 11 March 1996 (CDL (96) 15)) adopted at the 27th Meeting of the Venice Commission on 17-18 May 1966 (A. MILENKOVA, H. STEINBERGER, S. BARTOLE, L. AGUIAR DE LUQUE, J. KLUCKA, G. BATLINER, C. SVOBODA)

CDL(1996)018 English 10/04/1996 - Public
Opinion on the section relating to local authorities and other provisions concerning local self - government in the draft Constitution of Ukraine (A. DELCAMP)

CDL(1996)018 French 02/04/1996 - Public
Avis sur le chapitre relatif aux pouvoirs locaux et les autres dispositions intéressant l'autonomie locale du projet de la Constitution d'Ukraine (A. DELCAMP)

CDL(1996)014 English 12/03/1996 - Public
Comments on the draft Constitution of Ukraine / the State prosecution (C. SVOBODA)

CDL(1996)014 French 12/03/1996 - Public
Remarques sur le projet de Constitution d'Ukraine, le parquet d'Etat (C. SVOBODA)

CDL(1996)089 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Law on the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, Kyiv, 1996

CDL(1996)067 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Comments on the Constitution of Ukraine (A. MILENKOVA, S. BARTOLE, J. KLUCKA, G. BATLINER)

CDL(1996)059 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Constitution of Ukraine, adopted at the fifth session of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on 28.06.1996: Official English translation

CDL(1996)058 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Constitution of Ukraine, adopted by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine on 28.06.96

CDL(1996)025 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Comments on the draft Constitution of Ukraine (H. SUCHOCKA)

CDL(1996)019 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Comments on the draft Constitution of Ukraine (CDL(96)15) (A. MILENKOVA, H. STEINBERGER, S. BARTOLE, L. AGUIAR DE LUQUE, J. KLUCKA, G. BATLINER, C. SVOBODA)

CDL(1996)015 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Draft Constitution of Ukraine / approved by the Constitutional Commission - 11.03.96

CDL-NAT(1996)006 French 01/01/1996 - Public
Tableaux récapitulatifs des réponses au questionnaire sur les incidences de la succession d'Etats sur la nationalité

CDL-NAT(1996)006 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Summary tables of replies to the questionnaire on the consequences of state succession for nationality

CDL-DI(1996)004 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Replies to the questionnaire on "the consequences of state succession for nationality" (Albania, Argentina, Austria, Belarus, Bulgaria, Canada, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Georgia, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Kyrgyzstan, Latvia, Liechtenstein, Lithuania, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland, Sweden, Turkey, Ukraine)

CDL-NAT(1996)002 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Replies to the questionnaire on the consequences of state succession for nationality

CDL(1996)001 English 01/01/1996 - Public
Drafts for a new Ukrainian Constitution

CDL-IMM(1996)002prov French 01/01/1996 - Public
Annexe 1 : Tableaux récapitulatifs des réponses au questionnaire sur le régime des immunités parlementaires

CDL-IMM(1996)002prov English 01/01/1996 - Public
Annex 1: Tables summarising replies to the questionnaire on parliamentary immunity

CDL(1995)063 English 18/10/1995 - Public
Opinion on the draft Constitution of Ukraine: the People's Power (A. MILENKOVA)

CDL(1995)063 French 18/10/1995 - Public
Avis sur le projet de Constitution de l'Ukraine (CDL(95)28) / Chapitre III / Le pouvoir du peuple (A. MILENKOVA)

CDL(1995)040 English 11/09/1995 - Public
Opinion on the present constitutional situation in Ukraine following the adoption of the Constitutional Agreement between the Supreme Rada of Ukraine and the president of Ukraine

CDL(1995)040 French 11/09/1995 - Public
Avis sur la situation constitutionnelle actuelle en Ukraine à la suite de l'adoption de l'Accord constitutionnel entre le Conseil suprême et le président de l'Ukraine

CDL(1995)039 French 28/08/1995 - Public
Avis sur l'avant - projet de la Constitution de l'Ukraine: chapitre IV: l'exécutif (H. STEINBERGER)

CDL(1995)039 English 28/08/1995 - Public
Comments on the preliminary draft Constitution of Ukraine (CDL(95)38) - Part IV: The Executive (H. STEINBERGER)

CDL(1995)038 English 28/08/1995 - Public
Comments on the preliminary draft Constitution of Ukraine (CDL(95)38) - Part VI: Territorial system and territorial organisation of the powers (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(1995)038 French 28/08/1995 - Public
Avis sur l'avant - projet de la Constitution de l'Ukraine: système territorial et organisation des pouvoirs par territoire (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(1995)040prov English 25/08/1995 - Public
Draft opinion on the present constitutional situation in Ukraine following the adoption of the Constitutional Agreement between the Supreme Rada of Ukraine and the president of Ukraine

CDL(1995)060 French 01/01/1995 - Public
Avis sur le projet de Constitution de l'Ukraine (J. HELGESEN)

CDL(1995)060 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Opinion on the draft Constitution of Ukraine (J. HELGESEN)

CDL(1995)058 French 01/01/1995 - Public
Avis sur la Partie II "Droits et Libertés de l'Homme et du Citoyen" du projet de la Constitution de l'Ukraine (G. BATLINER)

CDL(1995)050 French 01/01/1995 - Public
Avis : Accord constitutionnel de l'Ukraine (N. V Vitrouk)

CDL(1995)049 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Opinion: Constitutional Agreement Ukraine (G. MAAS GEESTERANUS)

CDL(1995)048 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Opinion: Agreement between the Supreme Rada and the President (C. SVOBODA)

CDL(1995)047 French 01/01/1995 - Public
Avis : Accord constitutionnel de l'Ukraine (A. MILENKOVA)

CDL(1995)046 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Opinion Ukraine: The present constitutional situation (S. BARTOLE)

CDL(1995)029 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Constitutional Agreement between the Supreme Rada of Ukraine and the President of Ukraine

CDL(1995)028 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Draft Constitution of Ukraine / Preliminary partial draft

CDL(1995)025 English 01/01/1995 - Public
The Constitution of Ukraine / adopted 20.04.1978

CDL(1995)024 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Decree by the Ukrainian president on "certain questions of the relationship between the central bodies of state executive power of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea"

CDL(1995)017 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Draft Law of Ukraine on the Autonomous of Republic of Crimea

CDL-NAT(1995)003 English 01/01/1995 - Public
Appendix II: Summary Tables of replies to the questionnaire on the consequence of state succession for nationality

CDL-NAT(1995)003 French 01/01/1995 - Public
Appendice II : Tableaux récapitulatifs des réponses au questionnaire sur les incidences de la succession d'Etats sur la nationalité

CDL(1995)051rev English 01/01/1995 - Public
Memorandum: the Contemporary Constitutional Order in Ukraine (S. HOLOVATY)

CDL-NAT(1995)002prov English 01/01/1995 - Public
Replies to the questionnaire on the consequence of state succession for nationality (Albania, Austria, Belarus, Bulgaria, Croatia, Finland, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Japan, Kyrgyzstan, Latvia, Luxembourg, Moldova, Russia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Turkey)

CDL(1994)054 English 01/01/1994 - Public
Agreements establishing the Commonwealth of Independent States [Minsk, and Alma Ata December 1991]

CDL(1993)042 French 15/07/1993 - Public
Réunion sur le projet de Constitution de l'Ukraine: Note du secrétariat

CDL(1993)042 English 25/06/1993 - Public
Meeting on the draft Constitution of Ukraine: Secretariat memorandum

CDL(1993)048 English 01/01/1993 - Public
Draft Constitution of Ukraine 27 May 1993

CDL(1993)022 English 01/01/1993 - Public
Draft Constitution of Ukraine

CDL(1992)046 English 01/01/1992 - Public
Constitution of Ukraine

Venice Commission

Council of Europe

Documents

Activities

Press Multimedia

Useful links

Contact us